Straight answers and careful work on roof replacement in Fishers Island, NY. Metal roofing is our specialty, but we do the whole roof.
A new roof is one of the larger things you will spend money on, so Roofing Brothers keeps it orderly: written price, a firm start date, dry weather scheduled, and the house never left open overnight. Estimates are free and there is no pressure to sign the same day.
Roofing Brothers has been doing roof replacement since 2002, first around Morganton, North Carolina and now for Fishers Island homeowners through our network of local crews. The standard has not moved: measure it right, fasten it right, and never cut a corner where water can find it.
Before any roof replacement starts in Fishers Island you will know the price, the material and the schedule. Estimates are always free, and nobody is going to push you to decide while somebody is still standing in your driveway.
How a job actually runs, from the first phone call to the last magnet pass over the driveway.
Color, panel type or shingle line, and what the tear off involves all get settled before a thing is ordered.
The old roof comes off down to the deck and every board gets looked at. Soft spots come out and new goes in.
Flashing at chimneys, walls and skylights gets replaced rather than reused, because that is where old roofs start leaking first.
We walk the job with you before calling it done, and anything that is not right gets fixed right then.
Questions homeowners ask us about this kind of work.
We price both for Fishers Island homeowners so you can compare. Shingles cost less today. Metal costs more up front and usually outlives two or three shingle roofs, which is why it is the work we are known for.
A shingle roof on a typical Fishers Island home runs roughly $8,000 to $18,000 in 2026, and metal generally $12,000 to $30,000. Steep pitch, rotten decking and complicated cut ups push both numbers up. The estimate is free and it is written down.
Widespread curling or granule loss, decking that feels soft underfoot, leaks in more than one place, or a roof that has already had several repairs. We look at your Fishers Island roof and tell you honestly which side of that line it is on.
Not overnight. On Fishers Island jobs we only open what we can dry in the same day, so underlayment is down before anybody leaves the site.
What people said once the job was finished and the trucks were gone.
"They roofed our addition and tied in the porch that runs off it. One crew, one number to call, and every line of it matched up."
"Thank you so much to the entire crew at Roofing Brothers for our amazing new tin roof! You were amazing to work with and I couldn't recommend you to others enough! Great communication, pricing, color options, efficiency, and HONESTY! If anyone needs a new roof, I highly recommend this crew! Phenomenal job."
"Twenty year old tin roof with screws backing out everywhere. They refastened the whole thing with new washers instead of talking me into a replacement I did not need."